Great Mystery Games On PC

Mystery games are great choices for gamers who love detailed detective stories as well as fun puzzle games. Thanks to these often immersive games, fans finally get to be a part of their favorite stories and solve the most twisted and complicated crimes in gaming history. These games will let players go after dangerous murderers, become private detectives, or even a renegade cop who plays by their own rules.

RELATED: Best Detective Games, According To Metacritic

However, mystery PC games are capable of giving fans much more than a good brain teaser. Mystery game creators are great at choosing ambient music, building unique worlds, and increasing the gaming experience with stunning graphics so that players can face some of the best video game villains in a way they will never forget.

Updated September 21, 2023, by Via Erhard: PC Mystery games have been immersing players in some of the most intricate detective narratives while also unraveling some of the most complex stories, puzzles, and crime cases of the gaming universe. These games transport gamers into eerie but thrilling worlds, where they can play the role of relentless investigators, rogue detectives, or tenacious cops who adhere to their own set of rules. During their adventures, players can face monsters, serial killers, and mad scientists among many other supernatural and devious human foes. No matter if a player prefers realistic noir games or otherworldly experiences filled with beasts and evil ghosts, they can easily find an entertaining yet challenging mystery game. These brilliantly twisted games also sharpen players' skills as they tackle age-old mysteries that often draw inspiration from myths and folklore.

15 Frog Detective 3: Corruption at Cowboy County

Mystery fans can explore the quirky world of Frog Detective 3, where they'll get to step into the shoes of one of the cutest detectives who also happens to be a frog. Players will have to team up with Lobster Cop and solve an intriguing mystery of a sheriff-less county in the Wild West.

While Corruption at Cowboy County has a cartoonish art style it still offers players a twisty and engaging mystery without gore or scares. This fun mystery game on PC challenges gamers' detective skills while letting them explore a whimsical world. It's the perfect choice for casual gamers and avid players alike who enjoy games that let players play as an animal.

14 Scarlet Hollow

Scarlet Hollow transports players into a darkly atmospheric world where they'll have to uncover the mysteries and secrets behind their family's crumbling coal town. As players attend their aunt's funeral, they'll quickly realize that salvation may not be possible for everyone, not even for themselves.

RELATED: The Best 2D Super Mario Games, Ranked

It's a gripping horror-mystery game in which gamers will have to face the strange creatures that are terrorizing livestock while also dealing with the vengeful spirits infesting houses. Soon the peaceful Scarlet Hollow transforms into a hub of horrors. Players will have to uncover the eerie mysteries if they want to survive. Scarlet Hollow also has a beautiful art style as well as a complex story that keeps players entertained at all times.

13 Beacon Pines

Beacon Pines immerses players in a unique experience as they embark on a mysterious adventure that unfolds within the pages of a peculiar book. Players will become both the book's reader and its protagonist, Luka.

As players explore this odd and mysteries-filled world they'll get to participate in late-night escapades, forge new friendships, and collect powerful words that hold the key to altering fate itself. Gamers will be guided by The Chronicle, an interactive story tree that evolves with their choices, as they navigate through turning points. Casual players can also find guides and useful beginner tips for Beacon Pines to make their experience a great one from the start.

12 We Were Here Too

We Were Here Too is one of the twistiest mystery PC games set in a gorgeous and haunting medieval castle. It's perfect for players who love difficult brain-teasers and puzzle-solving since this fantasy-inspired co-op mystery game blends the two experiences perfectly.

However, players will not only have to use their problem-solving skills and creativity but also step up their communication and teamwork game if they want to uncover the castle's ancient mysteries and get out alive. Players will have to make hard decisions and solve imaginative puzzles while exploring the castle and communicating through their walkie-talkies. It's one of the most atmospheric mystery games that's perfect for casual and more experienced gamers as well.

11 Roman's Christmas

Roman's Christmas is one of the highest-rated mystery PC games of all time, with a charming fantasy-inspired art style, fun and furry characters, and surprisingly dark mysteries. This dark visual novel mystery game has a fun story that follows a wolf detective named Roman who wants to spend a quiet Christmas at his tavern, but because of the gruesome murder cases, he has no time to relax

It's perfect for gamers who love classic noir mystery games and are looking for one with a modern and LGBTQ+ positive story. Players will have to use their detective skills and step into Roman's shoes to find the murderer by examining evidence, all of the tavern's rooms, getting the other guests' testimonies, and of course, using Roman's special sniffing ability.

10 Project Kat - Paper Lily Prologue

Project Kat - Paper Lily Prologue is one of the most beloved psychological horror RPGs of all time with a twisty and dark mystery. It's a considerably short game but a highly entertaining one, and it has multiple endings that depend on the players' actions.

It's one of the spookiest and funniest mystery PC games in which a few selected characters get a mysterious golden letter, and players have to find out what's inside. In this fun atmospheric mystery game, players get to explore a spooky school after dark while solving challenging puzzles, completing minigames, and making new friends and enemies.

9 The Rewinder

The Rewinder is one of the most intriguing new mystery PC games that was inspired by Chinese mythology and art. It has hauntingly beautiful pixel graphics inspired by Chinese ink paintings while its twisty mystery story was inspired by ancient Chinese myths. Players get to go on a spooky puzzle adventure and become a supernatural detective named Yun, who is the last known Rewinder.

Yun has to travel to a small Chinese village and find out what happened seven years ago. The mysterious event turned the once vibrant village into a haunted place that's flooded with resentful spirits. Players will have to use Yun's special supernatural abilities and communicate with the spirits if they want to solve the dark mystery.

8 L.A. Noire

This film noir-inspired detective action game is perfect for players who are looking for classic mysteries. It's an interactive story that's set in 1947, Los Angeles, and is one of the best immersive open-world games in a historical setting where players get to become an L.A. Cop named Cole Phelps. Players have to solve various crimes, including brutal serial murder cases, do suspect interrogations, go to crime scenes, and of course, find and solve all the clues in this atmospheric game.

L.A. Noire is also a great choice for casual gamers and newbies because it's not only one of the best of its kind but one that lets players skip sequences they find too difficult, which makes the game much more enjoyable for all types of gamers.

7 The Wolf Among Us

The Wolf Among Us is an episodic graphic mystery game based on the beloved Fables comic book series and is one of the best games for true crime fans who also love twisted versions of fairy tales. In this visually beautiful game, fairytale characters are getting murdered, and players will control the protagonist of the story, Detective Bigby AKA Big Bad Wolf, who is the sheriff of Fabletown.

While it's a fairy tale character-based game, it's still a mature thriller story with some pretty gruesome murders. The investigation isn't as detailed in this game, but every choice the player makes has a serious impact on the outcome of the story.

6 Lucifer Within Us

Lucifer Within Us is a great choice for gamers who are into demons and all things supernatural. In this supernatural mystery game, players can take on the role of a digital exorcist and use their deduction and observation skills to solve increasingly intricate murders involving demons who forced people to commit these terrible crimes.

RELATED: Supernatural: The Best Dean Moments

During the investigation, players have to examine all the evidence, including testimonies of the suspects, purify the possessed, and even purge demons if they can find them. It's a fun game that will give players a unique story and some great opportunities to use their wits.