Summary

  • Sports games still provide fun offline gameplay, with career modes immersing players in managing clubs or athletes.
  • Best sports games for career modes offer great mechanics, unique paths, and memorable experiences.
  • Games like Motorsport Manager, F1 24, and NBA 2K16 provide immersive career modes with engaging gameplay.

Despite sports games increasingly prioritizing online modes that connect players worldwide in competitive matches, they still offer plenty of enjoyment through offline gameplay. Career modes immerse players in managing clubs or stepping into the shoes of an athlete, guiding an underdog team to the pinnacle of the sports world.

Great-Sports-Management-Games-That-Are-Not-Football-Manager
Great Sports Management Games That Are Not Football Manager

For those who enjoy the sports management genre but are tired of Football Manager, these are the perfect choices to branch out.

The best sports games for career modes are those that feature great mechanics, allowing players to fully immerse themselves in the journey. Building unique paths and achieving key milestones, such as securing a major championship, keeps the experience fresh. Even after multiple playthroughs, these games still provide new, exciting stories and memorable moments.

10 Motorsport Manager

A Great Game For Motorsport Fans

Motorsport Manager
Display card tags widget
Simulation
Sports
Strategy
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
August 21, 2014
Platform(s)
Nintendo Switch, Linux, Microsoft Windows, iOS, macOS
Genre(s)
Simulation, Sports, Strategy
OpenCritic Rating
Strong

Although it’s not as intricate as some other sports simulations, Motorsport Manager offers an excellent career mode for fans of motorsports. One of its standout elements is its active modding community, which provides a variety of modifications inspired by real-world competitions. For those not fully satisfied with F1 Manager, a range of Formula 1-themed mods is available, broadening the experience.

At its core, Motorsport Manager delivers on its own merits. Players can dive into detailed car development systems, designing and customizing new parts to improve race performance. Meanwhile, hiring top drivers and assembling a skilled pit crew further enhances the immersive feeling of managing a high-stakes motorsport team.

9 F1 24

Enhanced Career Mode Mechanics

F1 24
Display card tags widget
Racing
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
May 31, 2024
Developer(s)
Codemasters
OpenCritic Rating
Strong
Genre(s)
Racing

F1 24 revamps its career mode by letting players step into the shoes of renowned real-world drivers like Lewis Hamilton or Max Verstappen for the first time. This innovation adds depth by allowing users to inherit the chosen driver’s stats and long-term goals, along with facing dynamic challenges tied to their legacy.

To heighten authenticity, F1 24 includes secret meetings simulating high-pressure negotiations, while unique car characteristics reflect each team’s distinct advantages and drawbacks. Players can shape development priorities after earning lead driver status. Additionally, the My Team mode caters to those who prefer managing the broader aspects of an F1 team throughout a season.

8 NBA 2K16

Simple Yet Engaging Gameplay

NBA 2K16
Display card tags widget Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
September 29, 2015
Developer(s)
Visual Concepts
Platform(s)
PC, PS3, PS4, Xbox 360, Xbox One, Android, iOS
Genre(s)
Sports
OpenCritic Rating
Mighty

Early installments of the NBA 2K series serve as prime examples of how to design career modes, and NBA 2K16 is a standout title. Its gameplay balanced depth and accessibility, avoiding overly complex mechanics, making the experience both beginner-friendly and consistently enjoyable.

NBA 2K16 also refrained from the monetization strategies that became more common in later entries, emphasizing a straightforward, fun-first philosophy. Although the narrative wasn’t deeply intricate, it offered just enough intrigue to keep players engaged through the initial seasons of their basketball journey.

7 FIFA 23

A Solid Experience For Soccer Fans

FIFA 23
Display card tags widget Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
September 27, 2022
Developer(s)
EA Vancouver, EA Romania
Genre(s)
Sports
OpenCritic Rating
Strong

Soccer games often spark debate among fans. Some prefer the straightforward approach of older titles, while others appreciate the complexity of modern simulations. FIFA 23 strikes a balance, providing excellent gameplay dynamics that shine in offline play, particularly for those who enjoy a robust career mode.

NCAA and EA Sports College Football Game Cover Art
Best College Football Games, Ranked

College Football games offer distinct, enjoyable experiences from their NFL counterparts. Here are the best College Football games to play.

The experience is most immersive when engaging with Europe’s top leagues, whether playing as an individual athlete or a manager. Fully licensed teams and players add authenticity, which greatly enhances the connection fans feel to the real-world soccer environment.

6 PES 2013

A Standout Career Mode With Become A Legend

  • Plataforms: Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 2, PlayStation Portable, Wii, 3DS and PC
  • Developers: Konami
  • Released: September 20, 2012
  • Genre: Sports

For players who relish a deep dive into the career mode experience, PES 2013 offers one of the most engaging options in the soccer genre. Although its gameplay feels more arcade-like by today’s standards, its Become A Legend mode remains a highlight, with thoughtfully crafted mechanics that keep players invested.

The inclusion of cinematic sequences was impressive for its time, adding immersion for those who love feeling like part of the narrative. From grand stadium introductions of star players to vibrant trophy ceremonies, PES 2013 captures the essence of a professional athlete’s journey with memorable details.

5 College Football 25

Road To Glory Is An Amazing Career Mode

EA Sports College Football 25
Display card tags widget Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
July 19, 2024
Developer(s)
EA Orlando
Genre(s)
Sports
OpenCritic Rating
Strong

Though college football shares many fundamentals with the NFL, key differences help it stand apart, and College Football 25 successfully represents these nuances. It’s a top-tier football simulation that immerses players in the development of promising athletes chasing their collegiate dreams.

The Road to Glory mode is particularly captivating, offering a career mode that goes beyond the field. Players must manage their character’s life off the gridiron to remain in peak condition. Plus, it’s possible to transfer a player from College Football 25 to Madden NFL, continuing the journey seamlessly across the football landscape.

4 ESPN NFL 2K5

A Classic Kept Alive By The Modding Community

  • Plataforms: PlayStation 2, Xbox
  • Developers: Visual Concepts
  • Released: June 20, 2004
  • Genre: Sports

Even two decades after its release, ESPN NFL 2K5 remains noteworthy for delivering engaging mechanics and one of the most immersive career modes ever. Though it may not have today’s quality-of-life improvements, it still stands strong as an absorbing football experience.

The game featured iconic ESPN commentary and a dynamic franchise mode that allowed for quick yet engrossing sessions. Beyond its timeless appeal, an active modding community continues to update team rosters and other elements, keeping ESPN NFL 2K5 current and ensuring new generations of players can enjoy its legendary gameplay.

3 MLB The Show 24

Players Can Enjoy A Baseball Career Mode

MLB The Show 24
Display card tags widget Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
March 19, 2024
Developer(s)
San Diego Studio
Franchise
MLB The Show
Genre(s)
Sports
OpenCritic Rating
Strong

For those who love stepping up to the plate and hitting home runs throughout the season, MLB The Show 24 delivers precisely that. Improved mechanics and refined gameplay make its Road to The Show mode even more enjoyable to explore than in previous entries.

Football Manager 2024, F1 Manager 2024, Motorsport Manager
Best Strategy Sports Games, Ranked

Sports games are some of the most popular titles around, but the sports strategy niche is less well known, and features some fantastic games as well.

Among the best career modes in all sports games, MLB The Show 24 takes players through multiple seasons, allowing them to evolve and refine their skills. Additionally, the Franchise Mode offers an alternative focus - managing every facet of the team rather than just controlling a single athlete’s path.

2 Out Of The Park Baseball 25

Perfect For Players Who Prefer Managing A Baseball Team

  • Plataforms: PC
  • Developers: Out of the Park Developments
  • Released: March 15, 2024
  • Genre: Sports

While MLB The Show excels at action-oriented baseball gameplay, Out of the Park Baseball 25 truly shines for those who prefer deep management mechanics. This title provides an exceptional challenge, though its complexity can be overwhelming for newcomers.

Holding licenses from major leagues worldwide - such as MLB and KBO - OOTP25 allows players to develop new talent and nurture future baseball legends. Once you master the intricate mechanics, Out of the Park Baseball 25 becomes a highly rewarding experience, offering endless possibilities for building unique career mode journeys.

1 Football Manager 24

The Best Soccer Game For Career Mode

Football Manager 2024
Display card tags widget
Management
Simulation
Sports
Display card system widget
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info
Display card community and brand rating widget

Released
November 6, 2024
Developer(s)
Sega
Genre(s)
Management, Simulation, Sports
OpenCritic Rating
Strong

Among soccer simulations, the Football Manager franchise stands out for providing one of the finest career mode experiences in gaming. Its primary focus rests entirely on management, with players overseeing transfers, training, and tactics rather than controlling the athletes on the field.

Football Manager 24 offers a massive database of clubs and leagues from around the world, each with detailed player profiles and attributes. While guiding a top-tier English Premier League team is engaging, leading an underdog side from a smaller league, like Ireland, to global stardom is equally rewarding. This depth and flexibility make Football Manager 24 an ideal choice for dedicated fans of the genre.

FIFA 16, Out of The Park and Football Manager
Most Realistic Sports Games, Ranked

Those who like a good dose of realism in their sports games need not look further than these immersive sports titles.

2