Blue Prince Gives Animal Well a Run For Its Money in One…

Summary

Blue Prince is the highest-reviewed game of 2025 so far, praised for its absorbing experience and clever design.
Animal Well and Blue Prince offer multiple layers of secrets, puzzles, and optional content.
Blue Prince's roguelike and random elements add further challenges for fans who want to solve everything, requiring patience and a hint of luck to solve.

After only about a week since its release, Blue Prince has been getting rave receptions, being the most highly-reviewed title of 2025 at the time of writing, with a 90 average critic score on OpenCritic and finding itself in the discussion as a potential Game of the Year contender. The debut from developer Dogubomb that took eight years for creator, director, and designer Tonda Ros to refine and perfect, Blue Prince has proven all that hard work paid off, as, despite being a more niche and experimental "roguelike puzzler," it has already garnered heaps of praise for its absorbing experience.

The situation in many ways mirrors that of Animal Well, last year's hit indie Metroidvania, and the first title published under popular content creator Videogamedunkey's Bigmode label. Animal Well made a huge splash as well, instantly drawing many players into its beautiful but haunting labyrinthine world. More than that, the two also share the trait of having layers upon layers of secrets and optional content to discover, and Blue Prince might just have taken the crown from Animal Well in this regard due to its nature and design.

Animal Well was also nominated for Best Debut Indie Game and Best Independent Game at The 2024 Game Awards, and sits at an 89 on OpenCritic.

Why You Might Be Sleeping on the Best-Reviewed Game of 2025

2025's currently highest reviewed title is one that many might be missing out on due to its lower profile, but is an incredibly engaging experience.

Posts

By J. Scott Thurlow

How Blue Prince One-Ups Animal Well's Treasure Trove of Secrets

Blue Prince and Animal Well's Rabbit Hole of Hidden Layers

Both games present players with initially simple goals: to escape the titular well and reach room 46 of the Mount Holly mansion, respectively. They gently guide gamers into their systems and let them experiment with the mechanics while slowly and organically introducing more wrinkles and elaborate combinations and possibilities. Eventually, players are armed with the knowledge and tools to overcome previous obstacles and solve puzzles that were locked off earlier.

What sets Blue Prince and Animal Well apart is that, once completing a playthrough and reaching the ostensible end, this really only marks the beginning of a series of carefully involved steps and even more devious puzzles. Though many of these are technically optional, they offer additional context to their stories and settings along with different endings. Both titles beckon players to keep digging under the surface and explore their worlds further to see, and solve, greater mysteries.

Blue Prince is currently available on Xbox Game Pass Ultimate and PlayStation Plus' Extra and Premium tiers. Animal Well is available on the latter two.

Blue Prince's Design Presents a More Diabolical Challenge For Hardcore Completionists

Solo developer Billy Basso stated ahead of its release that he thought that it might take years for players to even uncover, let alone solve, all of Animal Well's meticulously hidden riddles. Fans answered in kind, though, and a dedicated crowdsourcing community went to work to share their discoveries in an endeavor to decode all the cryptic clues. Sometimes this involved simple brute-force, while others were pasted together from all the carefully laid breadcrumbs to arrive at the correct solution. It's still unknown if every single secret in Animal Well has indeed been unearthed, but many have, and much faster than its creator anticipated.

Blue Price offers a similar incorporation of deeper layers well beyond its starting puzzle. However, its roguelike elements prevent some of the methods used to crack Animal Well's from being as effective. In both, most of the clues are there for those who pay careful attention and take note of subtle hints. But whereas in Animal Well, once the answer is known, it's just a matter of following the exact steps, however complicated, to solve, Blue Prince often thwarts this strategy.

Blue Prince's use of randomness makes attaining certain solutions leagues more difficult, since, even if players have previously figured out what to do, they may not get all the pieces needed to complete a given puzzle in a single pass. It throws an extra layer of challenge into the mix, remaining fair but requiring more patience and, admittedly, a bit of luck, to achieve. Still, it can be incredibly satisfying to have everything fall into place on a perfect run. Like Animal Well, Blue Prince's plethora of extra secrets are enticing to complete, and it will likely be a game that inspires future titles to attempt to go even further in this area.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image