Elden Ring Nightreign has provided FromSoftware with a new environment to test some pretty unusual ideas in, and many comparisons are being drawn between it and the studio’s upcoming game The Duskbloods. Both games flip prior expectations of FromSoftware’s catalog, putting multiplayer front and center, putting the developer’s stamp on some unusual genre picks.

While Elden Ring Nightreign is quite experimental with a lot of its features, one of the biggest is pretty down-to-earth as far as multiplayer games go. However, when done wrong, it can make or break multiplayer titles. If The Duskbloods is going to be a success, Nightreign could be the testing ground for making sure the next game gets its character classes right.

Blasphemous Could Use Its Own 'Elden Ring Nightreign'
Blasphemous Could Use Its Own 'Elden Ring Nightreign'

Elden Ring Nightreign offers a unique take on its main title, and Blasphemous is set up well to follow suit with a similar experience.

The Duskbloods’ Roster of Playable Characters Looks to Be Expanding on Elden Ring Nightreign’s

Distinct character classes are a pretty novel thing for FromSoftware’s Soulslikes, which, with the exception of Sekiro, have given players complete freedom to build a character how they choose. The eight Nightfarers in Nightreign are unusual for being so locked down, each specializing in set roles with little room to pivot to others on the go. This has been met with some mixed reactions, as some people seem to love how each Nightfarer feels completely different to the last, whereas other players miss the blank slate characters that made them feel like they were truly a part of the world.

When details about Nightreign’s classes emerged, it was a very novel thing indeed, but not long after, FromSoftware surprised a lot of people by revealing The Duskbloods, a new game that featured even more characters. According to the studio, The Duskbloods will have over a dozen playable characters, showing just how ready it is to double down on this feature. Many of these have been glimpsed in trailers, each one seeming to be drawn from different parts of the game’s timeline, following a similar theme to Nightreign’s own classes.

How Nightreign’s Nightfarers Could Inform the Duskbloods’ Characters

There are already quite a few lessons The Duskbloods can learn from Nightreign, some of which concern characters. Nightreign has shown that FromSoftware is absolutely capable of making memorable, individual characters, as the internet is already full of memes about what the various Nightfarers do when not in Limveld. One thing that it has also shown, however, is that FromSoftware struggles to balance them. While it is to be expected that not all characters will be equally viable, certain ones have playstyles that stand head and shoulders above the rest, such as Ironeye, whose specialism in Bows puts emphasis on the enemies to react to the player, and not the other way around.

Each character will feel different to different players, and what one person says is weak might suit another person's playstyle incredibly well.

Nightreign can get away with unbalanced classes somewhat due to the fact that it is purely PVE. However, The Duskbloods will have to be extra careful about this aspect, as its design is centered around a PVP extraction format. If FromSoftware doesn’t reign in some of the more powerful classes in Nightreign, it could be taken as a sign that The Duskbloods could suffer worse balancing woes which would adversely affect the PVP environment. FromSoftware has always had a shaky history with balancing its invasion mechanic, but as it was only a side feature of past games, it was never going to be a top priority. All this changes in The Duskbloods, and how the studio handles balancing the Nightfarers may spell good or bad news about the larger roster of characters in FromSoftware’s Switch 2 exclusive.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image
Elden Ring Nightreign Tag Page Cover Art
Display card tags widget
Action RPG
Soulslike
Roguelite
Display card system widget
Systems
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget
Top Critic Avg: 80 /100 Critics Rec: 78%
Display card main info widget
Released
May 30, 2025
Developer(s)
From Software
Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start
Elden Ring Nightreign Press Image 6
Display card media widget end

WHERE TO PLAY

DIGITAL
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info

Genre(s)
Action RPG, Soulslike, Roguelite