Summary

  • Hogwarts Legacy disappointed fans by not adequately addressing the consequences of using Unforgivable Curses, undermining the moral values of the Harry Potter series.
  • The relegation of Azkaban to a cameo appearance in the game allowed players to use these dark spells without facing significant repercussions, which goes against the spirit of the franchise.
  • A potential sequel to Hogwarts Legacy needs to have a more robust choice system that incorporates concrete punishments for using Dark Arts, reflecting the darker elements of the storyline and adding depth to the gameplay experience.

It is said that every action has its consequences. Some of the best RPGs often implement this saying to varying degrees of success through the choice system, a mechanic that has become a core identity of modern gameplay. The looming confinement of Azkaban was enough to deter evil-natured wizards in the Harry Potter mega-series, and many assumed the legendary prison would play an instrumental role in Hogwarts Legacy, especially with Unforgivable Curses on the cards. However, its muted presence disappointed a large section of Harry Potter faithful, and a sequel needs to correct the moral oversight.

In the build-up to Hogwarts Legacy's groundbreaking release in February last year, fans looked forward to the first high-profile project to explore the wizarding world through a console. Gamers relished a chance to use some of the franchise's most famous spells, and when Unforgivable Curses were confirmed to feature in Hogwarts Legacy, it triggered an excited wave of "Avada Kedavra" chants on social media.

Given the stigma and expulsion that came with the use of these evil spells in the source material, it was almost guaranteed there would be some form of punishment in the game. Instead, Hogwarts Legacy largely glossed over this moral check and balance, leaving a hole that a sequel would be remiss not to fill.

A Hogwarts Legacy Sequel Needs Checks and Balances

hogwarts legacy sequel azkaban
hogwarts legacy sequel azkaban

Azkaban's Muted Role in Hogwarts Legacy Took Away Some of its Shine

While there were many things Hogwarts Legacy did beautifully, from its exquisite rural depiction of Hogsmeade to the exhilarating rides on magical brooms, there were areas where the Avalanche game lacked the depth expected of it. Most pronounced of the title's misses was its treatment of Azkaban, where the Wizarding locale was restricted to a cameo appearance only available to the Hufflepuff house.

The relegation of the prison to a footnote meant players could use Unforgivable Curses largely unchecked, which doesn't line up with the characteristic Harry Potter spirit. Using these forbidden spells in front of other characters at Hogwarts did draw one-liner chides but had no real consequences to the protagonist's relationships.

The only observable objections to the abominable spells came from Ominis Gaunt, who severally warned against going down the dark path with Sebastian Sallow. Hogwarts Legacy later puts the decision to punish Sebastian for killing his uncle with Dark Magic squarely in players' hands, and depending on the choice, the Slytherin wizard could either walk free or await trial. Needless to say, fans expected more of an authoritative presence to deal with the wicked use of Dark Magic. The lack of a concrete punishment for using Unforgivable Curses in Hogwarts Legacy exposed the lack of depth in its choice system, and a sequel can't afford to toe the same line.

Hogwarts Legacy 2 Needs a Choice System Shake-Up

A potential Hogwarts Legacy 2 has to pay more attention to its moral compass, especially if the storyline contains elements just as dark (or even darker) than the first game. There is no doubt that gamers using Crucio against enemies for fun in Hogwarts Legacy should've spent some cutscenes with the infamous Dementors to force a change of playstyle. To add to the punishment, the stigma that comes with using the Dark Arts in the canon material should also apply in a sequel, where NPCs would adversely react to a player's presence in various degrees.

A sequel to Hogwarts Legacy already gives Sebastian Sallow a chance to lean into the deplorable parts of his character and become the next Voldemort, and gamers anticipate an increase in evil elements in the next chapter of the franchise's story if one ever releases. With the plot potentially becoming even darker, there must be requisite punishments for using the Dark Arts, whether in terms of reputation hits or a prison term where players will atone for their crimes. One way or another, choices will need to have balancing consequences in a sequel.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image
Harry Potter: Hogwarts Legacy Tag Page Cover Art
9 /10

Hogwarts Legacy
Display card tags widget
Action
RPG
Display card system widget
Systems
PlayStation-1 Xbox-1 super greyscale 8-bit logo PC-1
Display card community and brand rating widget Display card open critics widget
Top Critic Avg: 84 /100 Critics Rec: 88%
Display card main info widget
Released
February 10, 2023
ESRB
T For Teen Due To Blood, Fantasy Violence, Mild Language, Use of Alcohol
Developer(s)
Avalanche Software
Publisher(s)
Warner Bros. Games
Engine
Unreal Engine 4
Cross-Platform Play
Hogwarts Legacy doesn't have crossplay or crossplatform support
Cross Save
you can freely use your saved data between each console as long as you are connected to the internet and signed into the same account where the saved data was created
Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end

WHERE TO PLAY

SUBSCRIPTION
DIGITAL
PHYSICAL
Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info

Hogwarts Legacy is an immersive, open-world action RPG set in the world first introduced in the Harry Potter books. For the first time, experience Hogwarts in the 1800s. Your character is a student who holds the key to an ancient secret that threatens to tear the wizarding world apart. Now you can take control of the action and be at the center of your own adventure in the wizarding world. Your legacy is what you make of it.

Explore an Open World
The wizarding world awaits you. Freely roam Hogwarts, Hogsmeade, the Forbidden Forest, and the surrounding Overland area.

Be the Witch or Wizard You Want to be
Learn spells, brew potions, grow plants, and tend to magical beasts along your journey. Get sorted into your house, forge relationships, and master skills to become the witch or wizard you want to be Experience a New Wizarding World Adventure
Experience the wizarding world in an unexplored era to uncover a hidden truth from its past. Battle against trolls, Dark Wizards, goblins, and more as you face a dangerous villain threatening the fate of the wizarding world.

Franchise
Harry Potter
Genre(s)
Action, RPG
How Long To Beat
26 Hours
Metascore
84
PS Plus Availability
Extra & Premium