MLB The Show 25: Best Team Affinity Cards, Ranked

Summary

Team Affinity programs in MLB The Show 25 offer valuable player cards to enhance Diamond Dynasty teams.
Top-tier cards like Craig Biggio, Babe Ruth, and Rollie Fingers provide game-changing attributes and abilities.
Players can craft lineups with balanced power hitters, contact hitters, and dominant relief pitchers for ultimate success.

For MLB The Show 25 fans, building that dream team is a season-long quest, and the Team Affinity programs are a goldmine for talent. They are like the ultimate cheat codes in the virtual clubhouse, whether players are crushing enemies in Conquest matches or battling it out in Ranked Seasons showdowns.

These cards transform a roster from average to total awesomeness, offering MLB The Show players a chance to craft lineups that leave opponents scrambling. For players eager to get a competitive edge without breaking the bank on the marketplace, identifying the top-tier Team Affinity rewards is crucial. This list explores the cream of the crop, the players who are ready to make an immediate impact on any kind of lineup.

MLB The Show 25: 10 Best Rookie Cards, Ranked

Valuable additions to any Diamond Dynasty team, these top Rookie cards in MLB The Show 25 offer speed, power, and promise.

Posts

By Charlotte Nicholls

9 Hank Thompson

San Francisco Giants

Overall Score: 85

For Diamond Dynasty players assembling their early-game squads, versatility can be just as valuable as raw power. Hank Thompson is the kind of card that players need in their back pocket to bring out when the situation demands a versatile contender.

With 76 contact against right-handed pitching and 70 power versus lefties, he’s not rewriting the record books, but he’s no slouch either. His real magic lies in versatility: third base, second, left field, right field — he’s got it covered. For MLB The Show fans piecing together early rosters, that flexibility is gold.

8 Craig Biggio

Houston Astros

Overall Score: 85

Craig Biggio’s Team Affinity Card flips the script on what a catcher can be. With 75 contact against righties, 85 versus lefties, and an unreal 88 speed, he’s a rarity behind the plate. For players frustrated with slow-footed backstops clogging up the bases, Biggio is a breath of fresh air.

Imagine a catcher who can not only get on base reliably, but also swipe second, putting immense pressure on the opposing defense. His card comes equipped with beneficial quirks like "First-Pitch Hitter" and "Dead Red," enhancing his ability to jump on mistakes.

7 Frank Thomas

Chicago White Sox

Overall Score: 86

Frank Thomas’s card is a lifeline for players needing a right-handed bat to balance the lineup. When facing a string of tough left-handed pitchers, having a reliable counter is essential, and "The Big Hurt" is tailor-made for the job.

His card boasts impressive offensive numbers: 82 contact against righties and 80 versus lefties, complemented by 74 power against right-handers and a massive 96 power against southpaws. Given that many early-game standout cards can be left-handed, Thomas provides crucial lineup balance for players who are looking to even out their roster.

6 Kyle Schwarber

Philadelphia Phillies

Overall Score: 85

For players who want to make an immediate statement at the start of a game or require a momentum-shifting blast in a key moment, Schwarber is a dream come true. The card is pure, unfiltered power: 115 against righties, 105 versus lefties.

While his contact ratings are lower (62 against righties, 80 versus lefties), the sheer game-changing potential of his power is undeniable. His "Road Warrior" quirk enhances his performance in away games, and "Breaking Ball Hitter" makes him particularly dangerous against off-speed pitches. For players who want a bat that intimidates, this card is the ticket to total dominance in Diamond Dynasty.

5 Rollie Fingers

Milwaukee Brewers

Overall Score: 85

Rollie Fingers’s card is the bullpen boost every serious MLB The Show player must have. This card provides a crucial, high-quality relief arm for those intense late-game situations. When the game is on the line and players need a pitcher to come in and slam the door, Fingers is an outstanding option.

Iron Man card art, fantasy warrior with sword, and Solitaire game screen

9 Best Card Games On Mobile, Ranked

Looking to kill some time on your mobile device? These addictive card games are the answer!

Posts 1

By Ronald Immanuel

His pitching attributes are formidable for a reliever, showcasing an 85 H/9 (hits per nine innings) and an 88 BB/9 (walks per nine innings). His diverse pitch mix, featuring a sinker, slider, forkball, and a fastball, keeps hitters off-balance.

4 Andrew Miller

Cleveland Guardians

Overall Score: 85

This card is a nightmare for opposing hitters, especially left-handed ones. Miller boasts elite attributes for a late-inning reliever: an exceptional 105 H/9 and a stellar 117 pitching clutch rating that makes him a beast. His BB/9 of 57 isn’t flawless, but those swing-and-miss pitches more than compensate.

Additional minor boosts come from his "Homebody" and "Day Player" quirks. Miller is a top-tier relief pitcher, someone players can confidently hand the ball to when the game hangs in the balance.

3 George Brett

Kansas City Royals

Overall Score: 85

In a game often dominated by power, a player who can consistently put the ball in play and get on base is invaluable. That’s why George Brett’s card is a contact hitter’s paradise — 87 against righties, 93 versus lefties, and a vision of 99. He’s the guy who keeps rallies alive, rarely missing a pitch.

Brett's card is further enhanced by valuable hitting quirks like "Dead Red" and "Breaking Ball Hitter," making him even more powerful against fastballs and off-speed pitches. As one of the greatest hitters in Royals history, his in-game representation certainly lives up to the legend, providing a consistent offensive force that can anchor the top of any lineup.

2 Justin Martinez

Arizona Diamondbacks

Overall Score: 85

Justin Martinez's Team Affinity card brings the heat, making him one of the most intimidating bullpen arms in the early game. Martinez dominates with a 99 velocity rating on his pitches, which include a sinker, splitter, slider, and a four-seam fastball.

What makes Martinez goated is his "Outlier I" quirk, which can further boost his primary pitch velocity by up to 3 mph, making his sinker absolutely devastating. His Control is at 72, but when he’s blowing 100+ mph past hitters, precision’s just a bonus.

1 Babe Ruth

New York Yankees

Overall Score: 85

Babe Ruth’s Team Affinity Card is the undisputed champ of MLB The Show 25. Even as an early-game version, "The Sultan of Swat" packs an extraordinary punch, offering game-changing offensive potential from the moment players add him to their lineup. His hitting attributes are outstanding: 99 contact against left-handed pitching and a mighty 97 power versus right-handers.

As one of baseball's most iconic power hitters, his in-game card is fittingly loaded with impactful hitting quirks, including "Dead Red," "Breaking Ball Hitter," and "Bad Ball Hitter." These prove that he’s an untouchable powerhouse who can excel against various pitch types and in different game situations.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image