Every open-world fan knows the feeling of missing a hidden gem of a game due to a critic's review. But then, months, even years later, a passionate community emerges and out of nowhere builds a cult following. It’s not always about perfect graphics or seamless performance. Because when a game’s core gameplay loop clicks, even the most “broken” title can earn a second life as a cult classic.
Sometimes, the most lasting open-world memories come from games that force players to work a little harder, think a little deeper, or simply laugh at the jank. What follows is a ranked look at some of the most infamous open-world underdogs — games that critics panned, but players never stopped loving their gameplay.
8 Best Open-World Games To Play If You Are Tired Of Open-Worlds
These great games offer interesting open worlds that provide unique experiences, ideal for those who think open-world games have become cookie-cutter.
Risen 3: Titan Lords
Tactical Swordplay and Pirate Adventuring Done Right
Risen 3: Titan Lords
- Released
- August 12, 2014
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- m
- Genre(s)
- Action RPG
When most critics talk about Risen 3: Titan Lords, the focus lands on clunky animations, dated visuals, and a story that barely makes it out of dry dock. However, players who dig beneath the surface will find a classic Piranha Bytes design — a world where every corner hides a secret, and every fight tests timing and patience. Risen 3’s “Glory” system lets players spend experience points on attributes at any moment, ditching grind in favor of immediate reward and personalized builds.
The game’s tactical combat, which is widely misunderstood, is actually a lesson in risk versus reward. Instead of mashing buttons, players must learn enemy patterns, time attacks, and make use of dodges and stamina. Add in firearms and magic, and the result is a surprisingly deep system for those willing to adapt. The real draw, though, is exploration: islands filled with hidden caves, secret treasures, and world design that feels handcrafted and justifies overlooking the initial bumps.
The Technomancer
Martian Mayhem and Multi-Stance Combat Mastery
The Technomancer
- Released
- June 27, 2016
WHERE TO PLAY
The Technomancer is a sci-fi RPG set on Mars, featuring dynamic combat and an epic story line, where your choices will affect the fate of the Red Planet. You are a Technomancer, a formidable warrior harnessing destructive electrical powers. Embark on a perilous journey across a planet torn apart by conflict and infested with mutant creatures.
Travel with your companions, choosing between diplomacy, combat or trickery to resolve quests. Gain experience to level up your character, and learn new skills or upgrade perks across 4 unique skill trees. Loot, buy and craft more powerful equipment and weaponry for yourself and teammates, to stand a chance of surviving!
Only you can forge the destiny of Mars.
- Platform(s)
- PC, PlayStation 4, Xbox One
- Genre(s)
- Action, RPG, Science Fiction
Scoring a "Weak" 58 on OpenCritic, The Technomancer was hit hard by critics for its lack of polish, stiff animations, and repetitive backtracking through its otherwise atmospheric Martian world. This game introduces players to three distinctive combat stances: staff-wielding Warrior, shielded Guardian, and agile Rogue, all of which can be switched on the fly, even during mid-combo.
Here’s the cool part: each stance has its own skill tree, plus an extra one for Technomancy powers. This means players can mix and match abilities however they want, so every fight feels different and keeps things interesting. The story slightly meanders, and the production values are rough around the edges. But those who stick it out often fall in love with the chaos and satisfaction of mastering its layered combat.
Biomutant
The Combat Playground Where Customization Rules
BioMutant
- Released
- May 25, 2021
WHERE TO PLAY
If ever a game deserved to be described as a “combat sandbox,” it’s Biomutant. Players are dropped into a vibrant, post-human world where mutated animals run wild, and the only rule is to get creative. Customization is king. In the DNA-altering character creation, changing stats reshapes the hero’s appearance, while the crafting system lets players weld together bizarre weapons from scavenged junk.
Critics pointed out repetitive quests and a sometimes overbearing narrator, but fans fell in love with the kinetic freedom of Biomutant’s core combat. Mixing martial arts combos, gunplay, and mutant powers, the system rewards improvisation and mobility. Furthermore, the world itself is a visual treat, loaded with lush biomes and colorful ruins, even if the gameplay loop outside of combat can wear thin. For players who love experimenting and want a toybox of tools to play with, Biomutant is a fun adventure worth checking out.
ARK: Survival Evolved
Taming Dinosaurs and Crafting Legends in a Relentless Survival
ARK: Survival Evolved
- Released
- August 29, 2017
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- T for Teen: Blood, Crude Humor, Use of Alcohol, Violence
- Genre(s)
- Survival
ARK: Survival Evolved sits at a "Weak" 61 on OpenCritic. Critics slammed it for its technical problems and steep learning curve, but the community soon discovered that the real magic is in the grind. Every hour invested in taming dinosaurs, breeding super-creatures, or building a fortress means something here. Every loss is a gut punch, and every win is hard-earned glory.
8 Best Open-World Games That Everyone Should Play, Ranked
There's a reason that open-world games are so popular, and while there are countless choices available, these genre entries are must-play experiences.
The game’s greatest innovation is its complex taming and breeding systems. Players spend hours, sometimes days, domesticating the island’s creatures, only to throw them into the meat grinder of PvP, raids, or just plain survival. It’s not a game for the faint of heart, and the early experience can feel punishing. But for those who persevere, ARK offers an emergent, ever-evolving adventure powered by player ambition.
Outward
Survival and Preparation Above All
Outward
- Released
- March 26, 2019
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- M For Mature 17+ Due To Blood and Gore, Partial Nudity, Violence
- Genre(s)
- RPG
Outward takes everything players expect from a modern open-world RPG — fast travel, hand-holding, hero fantasy — and chucks it out the window. Here, the protagonist is not a chosen one, just another struggling adventurer trying to survive in a harsh, uncaring world. Survival is the star: food, sleep, temperature, and even packing the right gear are all part of the core loop. On top of that, there’s no minimap icon to follow, so navigation means actually learning the world’s geography.
Where other games auto-respawn players after death, Outward delivers “defeat scenarios,” from bandit imprisonment to waking up miles from where the character fell. This isn’t just a gimmick; it turns every loss into a new adventure and makes victory taste that much sweeter. Preparation is everything. Players routinely have to strategize with buffs, traps, and a careful plan before major fights, making the journey itself a series of meaningful decisions.
Elex
Jetpack Freedom and a Brutal Power Curve
Elex
- Released
- October 17, 2017
WHERE TO PLAY
- ESRB
- M For Mature 17+ // Blood, Strong Language, Suggestive Themes, Violence
- Genre(s)
- Action RPG, Open-World
Released to a score of 61 on OpenCritic, critics pinpointed the game's janky animations and brutal opening hours. But for patient players, it offers the ultimate “zero-to-hero” power fantasy. The game throws players into a hostile world with little guidance — no level scaling, no handholding; just pure, uncompromising freedom. The result? Every early victory feels monumental, and late-game dominance is deeply satisfying.
Elex’s jetpack isn’t just a gimmick; it’s the heart of its exploration. Players can scale cliffs, bypass threats, and reach secret locations, making the world feel alive and reactive in a way few RPGs attempt. Survival often means thinking vertically, not just running from icons on a map. Furthermore, for fans who love deep, systemic gameplay, Elex delivers. Faction choices truly matter, the world reacts to player decisions, and even minor quests can shape the endgame.
8 Best Open-World Games That Tried Something New, Ranked
The following open-world video games went against the norm by offering unique and innovative experiences that were applauded by fans and critics.