Master & Disciple

It wasn't just "player choice" that made Until Dawn work. It was the "consequences". When characters died because of your choices, they stayed dead and the narrative shifted to accommodate it.

This cannot be replicated in non-interactive media. The movies attempt to do so actually goes against the spirit of the game, along with erasing the core narrative that remains popular to this day. This concept would be a better fit for Dead by Daylight. Until Dawn would have benefited from a well made straight adaptation of the source material.