Although Rockstar Games has always grounded Red Dead Redemption in realism, Lemoyne, the game's southeastern region, quietly introduced a canvas that could support something more surreal. The ghostly fog of Bayou Nwa and the decaying remnants of old Southern estates could be more than just a setting. If Rockstar was to ever return to the action-adventure open-world game, a spin-off taking inspiration from South of Midnight could be the way forward.
Indeed, RDR adopting influences from South of Midnight wouldn’t demand reinventing the wheel—it would simply mean leaning into what’s already present, especially considering everything the state of Lemoyne already offers. Plus, Red Dead Redemption already had themes like crime, voodoo, and superstition in places like Lagras and Saint Denis.
Red Dead Redemption 1 Might Have the Perfect Blueprint For a New RDR Protagonist
It's unclear what's next for the Red Dead Redemption franchise, but the first game could inspire a surprising protagonist shake-up.
Lemoyne is Already Halfway to a South of Midnight-Style Red Dead Redemption Romp
Lemoyne is divided into two primary regions: Bayou Nwa and Scarlett Meadows. Bayou Nwa is the most visually aligned with South of Midnight’s brand as it exudes a Southern Gothic tone. It’s filled with thick mist, dilapidated fishing shacks, rotting wooden docks, and hostile alligator populations. The town of Lagras from RDR2, in particular, feels disconnected from time as its residents speak in dialects unique even within the Red Dead world, and its isolation makes it feel like a pocket dimension within the map.
On the other hand, Scarlett Meadows has that faded grandeur of old plantations and Confederate echoes that could thematically anchor a story about cultural decay, buried secrets, or mystical hauntings. The region’s ruined mansions, crumbling family legacies, and proximity to Saint Denis, inspired by New Orleans, create a believable backdrop for a more mythic, character-driven story, too.
Fans Would Appreciate a Spin-off That Doesn’t Break Red Dead’s Rules But Also Has Entirely New Dynamics
If a Red Dead spin-off was to channel magical undertones, it wouldn’t require fireballs or floating enemies. Cursed artifacts, whispered legends, or a protagonist with spiritual visions paint a picture here, and these elements wouldn’t contradict the Red Dead universe either if presented as ambiguous or myth-driven instead of supernatural facts. Rockstar already toys with this through NPC rumors, ghost encounters, and eerie side quests. A spin-off could turn that ambient weirdness into its main focus, and it may even diversify the lore instead of breaking it.
A Stylized Red Dead Could Expand the Brand Without Diluting It
One of Rockstar’s biggest strengths is its flexibility in tone, and a Red Dead spin-off could prove that the franchise can stretch without snapping. Just as Grand Theft Auto has evolved in both satire and storytelling formats, Red Dead could branch out into something artistically daring without losing its soul. The key lies in not remaking South of Midnight but in absorbing RDR’s DNA, rhythm, and myth-making and applying them to a familiar but underutilized setting.
A stylized, folklore-inspired Red Dead game around Lemoyne could explore forgotten rituals, generational trauma, and legends passed down in whispers. It wouldn’t compete with Red Dead’s mainline games, either, and instead it could complement them by making use of map regions that serve more as atmospheric filler in RDR2. In doing so, Rockstar could open a door to new audiences.
Red Dead Redemption 2
-
OpenCritic Reviews
- Top Critic Avg: 95 /100 Critics Rec: 93%
- Released
- October 26, 2018
- ESRB
- M for Mature: Blood and Gore, Intense Violence, Nudity, Sexual Content, Strong Language, Use of Drugs and Alcohol
- Developer(s)
- Rockstar Games
- Publisher(s)
- Rockstar Games
- Engine
- RAGE
- Multiplayer
- Online Multiplayer
- Cross-Platform Play
- N/A
