25 Years And One Remake Later, This Horror Sequel Still…

It's honestly hard to believe that the Silent Hill series has been running as long as it has. In that time, Silent Hill has seen plenty of highs and lows. From a variety of sequels to ill-fated live-action movie adaptations, the franchise has had a difficult time recapturing the magic of the first four games that Team Silent developed.

Thanks to Bloober Team's Silent Hill 2 remake, though, gamers have been reminded of what makes the original chapters so great. Like many, Silent Hill and Resident Evil were my introductions to horror games, but Silent Hill 2 stuck with me way more than the other three Team Silent entries did.

Silent Hill 2 is its own standalone story in almost every aspect, apart from the town of Silent Hill being the centerpiece. James Sunderland is on a vastly different path than the rest of the franchise's protagonists, and it makes Silent Hill 2 feel a lot more like a spin-off (in the best possible interpretation of the term) than an official piece of the quadrilogy. Don't get me wrong. Silent Hill, Silent Hill 3, and Silent Hill 4: The Room are all strong horror games in their own ways, but Silent Hill 2 just brings something darker and more visceral to the table.

Major spoilers ahead for Silent Hill 2.

Silent Hill 2 Takes a Nightmarish Town and Turns It Into a Punishing Personal Hell

Over the course of the franchise, the main antagonistic force in the Silent Hill games has been The Order. With Silent Hill and Silent Hill 3, the cult was integral to Harry Mason and Heather Mason's stories. In Silent Hill 4: The Room, The Order set the game's events in motion due to Walter Sullivan being raised by the cult and continuing its practices. But SIlent Hill 2 completely sets the fanatic religious group aside. This ultimately opens the door to a stronger standalone psychological story that dives into how deep guilt can manifest into a hellish personal journey.

James' Guilt is the Real Horror of Silent Hill 2

Ignoring The Order and instead making James Sunderland's time in Silent Hill be more about the manifestation of guilt and suppressing memories of horrible actions makes it one of the most unnerving series entries. Guilt is something many relate to, and James is a vessel to showcase the mental toll it can take. The unbearable shame of killing his wife, Mary, literally haunts him. And the way Silent Hill 2 portrays him and his guilt also makes him a deeply sympathetic character, despite his actions.

Until it's revealed that James murdered Mary, the player is seemingly on his side. However, the reveal forces players to reflect on everything and realize that they've been blindly supporting him. Every Silent Hill game has a quality that makes it unique, but Silent Hill 2's reveal is something that punches players deep in the gut and heart.

Silent Hill 2's Guilt-Focused Story Gave Life to the Franchise's Most Iconic Monsters

Pyramid Head
Bubble Head Nurses
Flesh Lips
Abstract Daddy
Mannequins
Lying Figure
Mandarins

Every monster in Silent Hill 2 represents a manifestation of James' guilt. The most notable are Pyramid Head and Bubble Head Nurses, but the entire monster roster is what pops up in a lot of gamers' minds when thinking about the franchise. Pyramid Head's hypermasculine physique and giant metal head make the character one of the most iconic monsters in gaming, but moreso, the sharp, rusted helmet hangs heavy, forcing his head down, symbolizing how James' shame is such a burdensome weight to carry around. The Bubble Head Nurses represent James' views of the opposite sex and his shame for smothering Mary, which is why their faces are covered and distorted. It's deeply uncomfortable imagery that cements itself in the player's mind.

James, Angela, and Eddie Form an Unholy Trinity of Shame and Trauma

Silent Hill 2's supporting characters are just as tortured as James. Between Angela's complicated feelings from killing her sexually abusive father and brother, and Eddie Dombrowski snapping and becoming violent after intense bullying, Silent Hill 2 is rife with tragedy that eventually leads to violence. All three of these characters carry guilt and anger in different ways, reflecting how everyone's reaction to trauma is unique to their own personal experience. Silent Hill 2's story isn't a plot about a cult. It's a deeply human story, and that adds a heavy extra layer of emotional weight.

Silent Hill 2 Doesn't Need the Other Chapters to Make it Impactful

Even if Silent Hill 2 ended up having a completely different name and the titular town wasn't used, it would still hit just the same. Silent Hill, Silent Hill 3, and Silent Hill 4: The Room all need each other because of The Order. It's a fascinating piece of lore, but it's simply not as scary as the fight against one's own trauma and guilt. To this day, Silent Hill 2 is one of the most iconic horror stories in gaming because of the relationship it depicts between James and the town. The Silent Hill 2 remake is further proof of its legacy and impact on the genre. Bloober Team and Konami could have easily started with the first Silent Hill, but its sequel was the one prioritized.

Konami is continuing its partnership with Bloober Team for the upcoming Silent Hill remake. After the first chapter gets the remake treatment, Silent Hill 3 may be next, although this is just speculation at this time.

The Silent Hill 2 remake marked a fresh start for the franchise. Silent Hill f's story honors Silent Hill 2's tone by keeping it a more grounded human story than a narrative focused around The Order. All Silent Hill games deal with trauma in some form, but removing the trappings of the other games, Silent Hill 2 becomes the blueprint for how to tell a story that isn't just terrifying and bleak, but also deeply emotional in a way that crawls under the skin and doesn't leave.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image