Silent Hill May Be Losing Touch with What Made It So Special

Summary

Silent Hill's authenticity may be at risk due to Konami's broad approach to development and lack of consistent creative vision.
New Silent Hill titles are being developed by various studios, potentially diluting the series' identity and tone.
Despite competition from other survival horror games, upcoming releases like Silent Hill: Townfall may still capture the spirit of the classic games.

Though Silent Hill has long been considered an important and influential horror series, particularly during the PS1 and PS2 eras, recent and upcoming projects run the risk of tarnishing its identity and spirit. Konami has several Silent Hill projects in the works currently, and while many players are feeling hopeful about the future, there are just as many, if not more, who are approaching this new phase of the franchise with apprehension.

Despite being intended to compete with Resident Evil, Silent Hill quickly became known for its distinct, decidedly intimate brand of psychological horror which would be expanded and strengthened in subsequent entries, especially Silent Hill 2 and Silent Hill 3. Team Silent stopped developing Silent Hill games following Silent Hill 4: The Room, and the franchise has trended downward in terms of critical and financial success with the release of subsequent entries, leading to Konami's current release strategy.

Silent Hill May Be Losing Its Authenticity

Konami's Broad Approach to Silent Hill Development Could Be Doing More Harm Than Good

In the days of Team Silent, Silent Hill had a clear and well-defined creative vision. Now, new Silent Hill titles are being developed by various studios, and while spreading an IP across a diverse set of creative minds can have its benefits, a series like Silent Hill, known for its esoteric and specific tone and approach to storytelling, may be better handled by a more consistent group of developers.

By broadening Silent Hill's output, particularly with contentious spin-off properties like the interactive community narrative experience Silent Hill: Ascension, there's a risk of diluting its identity, making it more of a brand than an authentic series of horror games.

This issue of authenticity is part of why so many fans were frustrated by the cancelation of Hideo Kojima's Silent Hills. While many players were undoubtedly just hoping to see Kojima's take on the franchise, excitement about Silent Hills was born more from the sense of the franchise having clear and well-defined creative leadership in the form of Kojima and Guillermo del Toro. This is what is missing from the current slate of Silent Hill games, which can feel more like safe, outsourced releases designed with franchise-building as the main priority.

Silent Hill Has a New Generation of Survival Horror Competition

It's somewhat fitting that, all these years later, Silent Hill will still be competing with Resident Evil when it comes to AAA survival horror. But Capcom is far from the series' only competition in the modern age. Several indie games, many of which are inspired by the original Silent Hill trilogy, have managed to successfully recreate or iterate upon Silent Hill's iconic style of cutting and dark psychological horror.

Even Resident Evil, which recommitted to horror with 2017's Resident Evil 7, takes notes from classic Silent Hill games. Additionally, major releases like Alan Wake 2 lean into compelling and cerebral horror elements. Horror gaming's evolution, even over just the past decade, makes for a more competitive landscape, one where simply rehashing old Silent Hill staples won't be enough to make the franchise stand out.

While there are benefits to a healthy dose of skepticism about the future of Silent Hill, a degree of optimism is not unwarranted. Promising upcoming releases like the Annapurna-helmed Silent Hill: Townfall and Silent Hill f may channel the spirit of the classic games while innovating with the help of firm creative direction, and the Silent Hill 2 remake might, at the very least, provide a worthwhile modern alternative to the fan-favorite Silent Hill entry.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image

Silent Hill 2

Display card tags widget Display card system widget

Display card community and brand rating widget

9 /10

Display card open critics widget Display card main info widget

Released: October 8, 2024

Display card main info widget end Display card media widget start Display card media widget end

Checkbox: control the expandable behavior of the extra info

Investigating a letter from his late wife, James returns to where they made so many memories - Silent Hill. What he finds is a ghost town, prowled by disturbing monsters and cloaked in deep fog. Confront the monsters, solve puzzles, and search for traces of your wife in this remake of SILENT HILL 2.

High-end Graphics and Sound
With ray tracing and other cutting-edge technical enhancements, the world of SILENT HILL and its unsettling ambiance is even realer than before.And with the inclusion of new, immersive soundscapes, you'll feel like you're standing in the thick of it.

Larger Environments
Explore locations and buildings that were once inaccessible, or are newly added in the remake. Enjoy the same acclaimed story, even while you experience the town of Silent Hill with fresh eyes across an expanded map.

Over-the-shoulder Camera
The remake moves from the original's fixed-camera viewpoints to an over-the-shoulder perspective, putting you closer to what James sees, for a more thrilling, more immersive experience as you explore the town and come face-to-face with monsters.

Evolved Combat Gameplay
Familiar weapons like the steel pipe and handgun make their return, but now with an updated combat system. Avoid attacks with carefully timed dodges, aim down sights, and more, making monster encounters more engaging and nerve-wracking than ever.