Why Geralt Possibly Playing Mentor in The Witcher 4 Could…

Summary

Geralt potentially serving as Ciri's mentor in The Witcher 4 reflects their existing relationship.
Ciri's role in The Witcher 4 is crucial, with Geralt's presence possibly overshadowing her.
Balancing Geralt's potential mentor role is vital to prevent him from detracting from Ciri's growth.

Since it has been confirmed that Geralt will be appearing in some capacity in The Witcher 4, a safe assumption would be that the series' longstanding icon will play the role of mentor to Ciri in the upcoming game. Throughout the series, Geralt has been portrayed as a father figure and mentor to Ciri, with that relationship especially depicted in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt with her first non-card appearance, so it wouldn't be too far out of reach for him to continue playing that role in The Witcher 4. Furthermore, Vesemir served as a mentor to Geralt in The Witcher 3, but with Vesemir's passing, it would be fitting for Geralt to fill this void by becoming the new lead mentor of the series, effectively mirroring the relationship he once had with Vesemir.

While longtime fans of the series are likely excited about Geralt's return in The Witcher 4, it might be troublesome for him to fill the role of mentor. In The Witcher 3, Vesemir played a very prominent role, especially in the early and mid stages of the game, so it's probable Geralt could rise to such prominence if he were featured as a mentor in The Witcher 4 as well. The main difference between Vesemir and Geralt, however, is that Geralt is a far more significant character than Vesemir, given his part as the series' protagonist until now. As such, Geralt as a mentor could potentially cast a dark shadow over Ciri's new role in The Witcher 4, so the game will need to tread lightly with its inclusion of him.

The Witcher 4’s ‘Immersive’ NPCs Could Bring One Radical Change

With The Witcher 4 confirming its NPCs will be more immersive than ever before, it might be time for the series to make a change in one major area.

Posts

By Josh Cotts

The Witcher 4 Needs to Tread Lightly With Geralt

The Witcher 4 Is Ciri's Time to Shine

Ciri might have been one of the most important figures in The Witcher 3, but never has her place in the series been more important than it will be in The Witcher 4. Not only will she be the next game's playable protagonist, but she will be replacing someone who is considered the very face (and voice) of the franchise, thereby making her new position all the more important. More than anything else, The Witcher 4 will need to pull out all the stops to ensure Ciri is front and center if it hopes to establish her as the series' new lead, and that could be difficult to accomplish with Geralt in a mentor role akin to Vesemir's.

Geralt Playing a Mentor Role Could Distract From Ciri's New Role

The main thing The Witcher 4 will need to consider when determining how to balance Ciri's new role with whatever part Geralt has been positioned to play is the fact that Geralt has a pre-existing relationship with fans heading into the next game. While players had some time to develop a connection to Ciri in The Witcher 3, it hasn't been enough yet for them to truly establish something deeply personal with her. In other words, if Geralt's potential new role as a mentor is too active or central to the story, it might shift the focus away from Ciri's growth and journey.

If Geralt were to play the part of mentor to Ciri in The Witcher 4, it would still be understandable for some fans to still see Geralt as the sole Witcher. As such, The Witcher 4 would need to ensure Geralt is strictly a mentor and fills no protagonistic role of any kind, lest he and Ciri be seen as dual protagonists, thereby ruining Ciri's shot at taking the lead. To ensure this balance happens, perhaps one part of The Witcher 4's story could center around Ciri stepping out of Geralt's shadow to become her own person, with Geralt then simply acting as a compass she can rely on willingly, rather than someone who holds her hand the entire time.

If nothing else, The Witcher 4 could avoid Geralt being a mentor altogether and merely have him make a cameo appearance in the game as a bit of fan service. Of course, this might not be enough for some fans, opening the door for unnecessary criticism directed at the game. In light of that, it may be inevitable that Geralt will be featured in some significant role in The Witcher 4. The real question is what that role will be, and whether the highly anticipated game can bring him in without squashing Ciri in the process.

Rating block community and brand ratings Image